Marking the birth centenary of Michel Foucault, an article written by VCK Member of Parliament D. Ravikumar explains how Foucault’s theory of power helps in understanding contemporary Indian politics.
He notes that Foucault highlighted how power is not merely concentrated in the hands of the state, the law, or the ruling class; rather, it operates through social relations, the production of knowledge, surveillance, and institutional practices. Furthermore, he emphasizes the role of civil society organizations in resisting the bureaucratic actions of the BJP government.
There is no doubt that Foucault’s insights help us understand the microscopic operations of power. However, the fundamental question to be raised here is: In whose hands does that power lie? How can the working class attain that power?
There is a vast difference between explaining how power operates and formulating a revolutionary political project to transform the economic and social relations that create and reproduce that power. Without clarifying this distinction, merely identifying the various manifestations of power cannot be regarded as a complete guide to social change.
This is the central question that must be discussed from a Marxist perspective in relation to Ravikumar’s article.
The objective here is not to reject Foucault’s theory. Rather, our aim is to examine how far its explanatory power extends, what its theoretical limits are, and how to evaluate them through the lens of Marxist-Leninist theory.
The Function of Power and Capitalist Relations of Production
Marxism does not view society merely as a collection of isolated power relations. It analyzes the historical movement of society based on relations of production, ownership of the means of production, the exploitation of labor, the extraction of surplus value, and class contradictions.
In capitalist society, the worker is forced to sell their labor power. The capitalist class, which owns the means of production, appropriates the surplus value generated by the labor of workers. This exploitation does not occur merely due to the attitudes of individuals; it is rooted in the structure of the capitalist mode of production.
Foucault’s analysis of power explains how power operates over human bodies, behaviors, knowledge, and social relations. In particular, his studies reveal how modern institutions control humans through practices such as surveillance, discipline, and evaluation.
However, Foucault did not provide a comprehensive political-economic theory that integrates the connections between these techniques of power, the ownership of the means of production, the accumulation of capital, and the exploitation of labor. This is the crucial limitation of his theory of power.
For example, the monitoring of a worker's time, the disciplining of their body, and the measurement of productivity in a factory can be explained as techniques of power. Yet, one must also examine how this discipline reduces production costs, strengthens capitalist control over labor, and aligns with the objective of increasing surplus value.
Here, the analysis of power and the analysis of political economy cannot be substituted for one another.
Knowing how power operates is important; the next step toward social change is to explain which economic relations sustain that power, whose interests it serves, and what political force is required to transform it.
If Power is Everywhere, What is the Distinctiveness of Class Power?
In Foucault’s thought, power is not concentrated at a single center. It operates through various social relations such as the family, school, hospital, prison, workplace, sexual norms, and the production of knowledge.
This perspective helps in understanding the various systems of control in modern society. However, there is a distinction between identifying the dispersion of power and evaluating the social significance of different power relations.
The power exercised by a teacher to control a student and the power exercised by a capitalist to control a worker’s livelihood and labor are not of the same kind. They may be related, but their economic foundations and social consequences differ.
Similarly, gender domination occurring within the family and class power operating through the ownership of land, capital, and the means of production cannot be evaluated on the same scale. Moreover, the theoretical importance of state power standing above and controlling society as a whole should not be underestimated.
This does not mean that the power operating within domains like the family, school, and gender relations is unimportant. Rather, we must identify how they interact with the economic structure, in what ways they reproduce social domination, and which contradictions possess the potential to transform them.
The objective of Marxist critique is not to reduce all forms of power in society to a single economic cause. It is to investigate the connections and contradictions among them and to explain the distinct role that production relations and class contradictions play in the overall reproduction of society.
Therefore, when evaluating Foucault’s theory of power, we should not merely take his assertion that power operates pervasively; we must also examine the extent to which he explains the relationship between those pervasive power relations and the underlying economic structure.
The Political Limits of Postmodernism: Can Social Change Emerge from Fragmented Resistance?
Certain political approaches associated with postmodernism understand society as a collection of diverse identities, experiences, discourses, and power relations. Such approaches can contribute to exposing specific forms of oppression and identifying hidden mechanisms of domination. However, a problem arises when this analysis is presented as a complete political program for social change.
Can social liberation be achieved merely by identifying each oppression separately, resisting the techniques of power in every institution, and creating counter-discourses for every dominant discourse?
It is essential to resist caste oppression, gender domination, religious majoritarianism, educational inequality, and police repression. However, unless the struggles against these are linked with a project to transform the economic relations and political structures associated with them, the overall system of exploitation will persist, even if resistance occurs at every individual level.
This does not mean that all identity politics is counter-revolutionary or that every specific struggle must ultimately end in mere reformism. Struggles against specific oppressions can be indispensable parts of social transformation.
What matters is how they are united, what their common social objective is, and what role they play in transforming the existing economic and political system.
Anti-power resistance severed from class struggle may alter certain manifestations of society, but it will fail to transform the structure that continually reproduces those manifestations.
This is the primary reason why certain political applications of Foucault’s thought must be critiqued on a Marxist basis. The critique here does not concern Foucault’s personal intent, but rather the limitations inherent in using his ideas as a comprehensive revolutionary political framework.
Civil Society: A Space for Resistance, Not a Guarantee of Liberation!
In his article, Ravikumar cites trade unions, farmers' organizations, women’s movements, Dalit movements, student groups, human rights organizations, and independent media as components of civil society. There is no doubt that these organizations can play a role in political change.
People can build political consciousness and resistance outside electoral parties as well. Such organizations can contribute to defending civil rights against state repression, articulating the voices of the oppressed, and expanding democratic struggles.
However, civil society is not a homogenous coalition of organizations sharing identical class interests.
There can be inherent contradictions between the interests of workers and capitalists. Differences exist between the interests of small farmers and large landowners. Organizations that safeguard workers' rights and those that seek to curtail workers' rights operate within the same social space.
Therefore, the democratic character of civil society cannot be determined by its name alone. One must examine its class foundation, economic interests, political objectives, and practical actions.
Ravikumar points out that caste dominance, religious majoritarianism, gender discrimination, and economic exploitation can exist within civil society itself. Yet, his article fails to offer detailed answers to questions regarding the political basis on which these contradictions should be confronted, how class contradictions among different organizations ought to be handled, or how democratic resistance can be linked to structural transformation. This represents its key theoretical gap.
Uniting in resistance may be politically necessary. However, the social transformative potential of that unity is determined by its objective, the class interests that guide it, and the changes it strives to bring about in the economic structure of society.
The Difference Between Anti-BJP Opposition and Anti-Capitalist Struggle
Opposing the bureaucratic actions of the BJP government, defending citizenship rights, and upholding secularism are vital tasks in democratic politics. Struggles against religious majoritarianism and state repression play a significant role in safeguarding people’s rights and political participation.
However, opposing a specific government does not automatically equate to opposing capitalist production relations.
An organization resisting a government’s religious majoritarianism and authoritarianism may simultaneously remain silent on issues such as private property ownership, labor exploitation, and capital accumulation. Even corporations that criticize certain state actions may do so merely to protect their own economic interests.
This does not imply that anti-BJP struggles are futile. Protecting democratic rights and confronting fascist tendencies and majoritarianism are necessary political imperatives.
Yet, what determines the trajectory of these struggles toward meaningful social transformation is their political content and class stance.
While various organizations spearheading anti-BJP resistance may share common democratic goals, contradictions among them regarding economic policies, workers' rights, private property, and the distribution of social resources persist.
Without analyzing these contradictions, all organizations resisting state power cannot be grouped together as a singular political force.
There is a distinct difference between an alliance formed to oppose the BJP and a revolutionary alliance aimed at transforming capitalist relations of production. Recognizing this distinction is the first step toward unifying democratic struggles with long-term projects for social liberation.
Caste, Gender, Class: Are They Mutually Exclusive?
Caste oppression and gender domination are not merely discursive issues. They are deeply intertwined with property rights, the division of labor, land ownership, education, employment, wages, and the distribution of social resources.
Separating caste oppression from its economic foundation risks underestimating the crucial roles played by land tenure, occupational opportunities, and the social division of labor. Similarly, treating gender oppression solely as an issue of personal identity or cultural discourse overlooks unpaid domestic labor, property inheritance, and inequalities within the labor market.
At the same time, reducing solutions for caste discrimination and gender oppression to mere side-effects of class struggle is equally an un-Marxist approach.
The caste system possesses distinct historical and social structures. Gender domination also operates across multiple domains, including the family, labor, property rights, social norms, and political representation. Struggles against these are indispensable components of social liberation.
Therefore, when identity politics attempts to substitute class struggle, its limitations must be pointed out and critiqued. Concurrently, depicting anti-caste and gender equality movements as hostile to class unity is equally flawed.
Class unity is not built by denying the specific experiences and demands of oppressed groups. Rather, it becomes possible only by understanding how caste dominance, gender exploitation, and economic exploitation interact, and by building a common political program to resist them collectively.
This is the central challenge of Marxist politics: not reducing diverse forms of oppression to a single economic cause, but comprehending their specificity and mutual interconnections, and linking them with the struggle to transform the fundamental structure of society.
Why Foucault’s Theory is Not a Complete Revolutionary Political Project
The significance of Foucault’s thought lies in his examination of the various micro-techniques through which power operates in modern society from new angles. His works elucidate how power functions through prisons, surveillance, discipline, medical knowledge, and social institutions.
However, a theoretical analysis of power is not the same as a revolutionary political project to transform society.
A project for social transformation must answer several fundamental questions:
• How will capitalist relations of production be transformed?
• How will the ownership and control of the means of production be resolved?
• What role will the independent political organization and leadership of the working class play?
• How will struggles against caste, gender oppression, and class exploitation be integrated?
• How is the relationship between political power, the class character of the state, and democratic rights understood?
• What economic, political, and institutional changes are required to create new social relations?
Foucault’s theory of power was not constructed as a revolutionary political economy capable of offering an integrated answer to all these questions. A comprehensive revolutionary strategy cannot automatically emerge from his theory alone.
This does not mean his insights should be discarded as useless. Rather, we should learn from his analysis of the microscopic operations of power while critically evaluating its limitations through Marxist political economy.
Instead of posing Foucault’s power analysis as a substitute for Marxist class analysis, it can be useful as an analytical tool to understand specific manifestations of power. However, that application must not replace the analysis of production relations, class contradictions, and social reproduction.
Diverting the Revolution: The Risk in the Political Application of Theory
Diverting a revolution does not always happen through intentional conspiracy. At times, the theoretical limitations of a political approach itself can dictate its practical consequences.
Resisting isolated manifestations of power instead of confronting class exploitation; reforming institutional mechanisms instead of transforming relations of production; fragmenting various struggles into disconnected spheres instead of unifying the common interests of working people—such approaches carry the risk of weakening the politics of social transformation.
In this context, how Foucault’s ideas are utilized becomes critical.
Using his power analysis to critique prisons, surveillance, caste dominance, and gender oppression can be a valuable contribution. However, if these analyses are completely severed from capitalist relations of production and isolated solutions are offered for each oppression, the unifying political project will be compromised.
The struggle then remains confined to resisting specific manifestations of power, while the question of transforming the economic and social structure that continuously reproduces that power gets pushed into the background.
Such an outcome may not be an inevitable consequence of Foucault’s personal thought, but it can be identified as a clear risk when his theory of power is deployed as a replacement for class analysis.
Therefore, rather than speculating on Foucault’s personal intent, a critique focused on the explanatory capacity, limitations, and specific political applications of his theory remains far more robust.
From Analyzing Power to Transforming Class Society!
Ravikumar’s article emphasizes the democratic resistance capacity of civil society and the microscopic forms through which power functions within social relations. These are useful elements for understanding contemporary Indian politics.
However, his article does not provide an adequate explanation for how to move from merely identifying various forms of power to constructing a political program that transforms the economic and social relations producing and reproducing them.
Foucault’s theory helps us comprehend the micro-mechanisms of power. Yet, it remains insufficient as a complete revolutionary program for transforming production relations, ending class exploitation, and altering the class nature of the state.
Marxism does not deny that power operates in manifold forms. Its strength lies in connecting those forms of power with relations of production, class contradictions, the political structure, and historical change.
Social transformation is not about changing discourses, merely criticizing institutional functioning, or organizing resistance separately under different identities. It is a collective struggle to transform the economic relations and systems of social domination that continually drive society into exploitation.
Foucault’s ideas may help identify specific forms of power, but they cannot replace class analysis. Civil society may be a space for democratic resistance, but it is not inherently revolutionary. Anti-BJP opposition may be an important political struggle, but it cannot substitute for a social transformation project aimed at capitalist exploitation.
Exposing the techniques of power is not enough. A political path is required to transform the class relations and structures of social domination that continually reproduce that power.
Understanding power is necessary; transforming the social relations that generate it is the fundamental goal of liberation.
This constitutes the core of the Marxist critique that exposes the limits of Foucault’s theory of power, the contradictions of civil society politics, and the political risks of anti-power resistance severed from class analysis.
— Tamilmani

